Doctor Who Earthshock [1982] [VHS] [1963] [VHS Tape] (2000) Peter DavisonDoctor Who: Earthshock finds Peter Davison’s Fifth Doctor nicely settling into the role, initially displaying some crotchety short temper that harks back to William Hartnell’s incarnation of the Doctor, effectively setting up the most emotionally powerful finale in the show’s 26-year run.
In this, the penultimate adventure of Doctor Who‘s 19th season, a scientific expedition in a cave system on 25th-century Earth is wiped out. An army rescue unit led by Lieutenant Scott (James Warwick) and including the one woman, Professor Kyle (Claire Clifford) who survived the original massacre, goes in to recover the bodies. The scenario deliberately evokes Ridley Scott’s Alien (1979), and uncannily foreshadows James Cameron’s Aliens (1986), developing into a tense actioner on a space freighter bound for Earth carrying a very deadly cargo of Cybermen.
Tightly paced, refreshingly free of the camp humour that sometimes blighted the show in the 1980s, and with a notable guest turn from Beryl Reid as the ship’s captain, Earthshock is one of the Doctor’s finest adventures. Overlook a few gaping plot holes and by the end they simply won’t matter; when the final credits roll in silence the effect is as powerful now as it was shocking to audiences back in 1981. If only Star Trek: The Next Generation had done the same to Wesley Crusher!
On the DVD: Doctor Who: Earthshock is presented in the original broadcast 4:3 with a near flawless picture, though the source videotape does show just the occasional sign of damage. The mono sound is excellent. The extras begin with a strong 32-minute documentary, more retrospective than making-of. Then comes the commentary, with Peter Davison, Janet Fielding (Tegan), Sarah Sutton (Nyssa) and Matthew Waterhouse (Adric), which like so many Who commentaries is both informative and wonderful fun. Both commentary and the episodes have optional subtitles. Other options include detailed on-screen information titles, an isolated musical score, and the ability to watch with selected effects shots replaced with new computer graphics. There’s a scored, five-minute photo gallery that even includes a shot from the recording of the commentary, a pointless assemblage of the seven minutes of footage shot on film, and a three-minute clip montage set to a dreadful techno reworking of the title theme to celebrate the show’s 40th anniversary. Much more interesting is a 10-minute section from arts review Did You See? looking back on the show’s aliens, and including clips from Earthshock, while the very brief Episode 5 is a hilarious new animation. –Gary S Dalkin
The Cybermen return with a crash Story: 4/5 – Extras: 5/5As I understand it, some people love writer Eric Saward’s “Earthshock” and some hate it. Just to be awkward, I’m going to say that I like it, but it’s not perfect.Earthshock carries with it a bleak atmosphere not uncommon in the Peter Davison era alongside such stories as Resurrection of the Daleks and The Caves of Androzani, particularly in the death-heavy first episode, with which its sequences of caves and androids is actually a massive diversion from the real enemies – the Cybermen – who only appear at the episode’s climax. I imagine that if I was watching Doctor Who in the early 1980s I’d have been pretty impressed with the revelation.I’ve never found 1980s Cybermen particularly menacing, but there’s no doubt that in Earthshock they do have a certain edge that they would subsequently lack in stories such as The Five Doctors. In Earthshock they really are a powerful force, breaking out of their hibernation silos in droves, murdering anybody who stands in their way and getting up to a fair amount of scheming, too. The voices may not be as chilling as they were in the late 1960s, but they’re more intelligible, and it does allow the Cyber Leader to have better lines.Other aspects are less successful. The numerous supporting characters introduced in episode one, such as Lt. Scott and his troops, become somewhat redundant once the story switches location to a space freighter in episode two (and picks up its new supporting characters in the form of the freighter’s crew), none more so than Professor Kyle, the leader of the archaeological expedition, who spends the rest of the story hanging around with Nyssa in the TARDIS until she eventually gets shot. Like many stories of this era, there are too many companions – but that, of course, is all about to change.Weaknesses notwithstanding, the plot of the story is well constructed and there’s a dramatic send-off for Adric as the TARDIS crew is reduced in number by one.Earthshock comes with a strong package of extras, including a chaotic commentary with the full TARDIS crew, a thirty minute documentary on the making of the story with numerous leading contributors, the usual on-screen production notes, a few film trimmings and bits and bobs from the TV archives, and informative on-screen production notes. Excellent.
Another great Who DVD Peter Davison is turning out to be the best represented Doctor on DVD with yet another classic story, this time from the beginning of his tenure. Yes, this is the infamous tale that not only brings the Cybermen back better than they ever were before, but also kills off a companion, whilst also finding time to account for the extinction of the dinosaurs.
Two shocks, in fact… …if you already own the DVD – this 2007 print is exactly the same as the extant edition, except they’ve slipped a natty blue sleeve over the old-style box. That’s not a criticism – just thought you ought to know in case you weren’t going to get it because it wouldn’t match yer other Who DVDs (you know what some people are like). It will – and as it’s mid-price you can buy new at pre-owned rates. As for the show itself… widely held to be one of the most satisfying adventures of the critically-rehabilitated Davison era, Earthshock offers a interesting contrast between his polite, exasperated, vulnerable Doctor and the cold, supposedly emotionless Cybermen. High production values and a fabulous, truly-filmic score mean it stands up very well, and nice add-ons round out the package. Episode four was the real shock, at the time… and if you don’t know why I won’t spoil it here… This is part of a re-booted DVD series aimed, one suspects, at tempting new, young Ecclestone- and Tennant-era fans to sample the ‘classic’ era, and no bad thing for that. Recommended.